Skip to main content

FoxPro is outdated - compared to what? (an example of what FoxPro developers are up against)

I recently heard of an interesting story - you can read about it here - related to how the FBI recently canceled a project for a management system. No big whoop there except that the vendor in question was selling a FoxPro application. The full PDF report (from the Auditor General) is available here .

Just so you don't need to read it - here are the parts that were interesting:

The customization was a slow process because the JusticeTrax LIMS relies on an aging code format, Visual FoxPro.While Visual FoxPro is outdated, it is still compatible with today’s technology. However, according to FBI personnel, Visual FoxPro is difficult and slow to customize compared to newer programming languages. While the extent of customization was the main obstacle, having to use the old code increased the delays.

Note: JusticeTrax's LIMS application uses VFP 9 and a SQL Server back-end. It is also used by a variety of law enforcement agencies and forensic labs across North America.

What was the FBI currently using?
The FBI currently uses Microsoft’s Access 2002 as the ECS database software.

The IMPRB expressed additional concerns about project risks, including the fact that the Visual FoxPro code used for JusticeTrax’s LIMS is old technology

Now there are a number of other reasons for the cancellation of contract (they wanted a web-based app - LIMS is a desktop app, poor project management, no champion, etc) but so many times, we hear that Microsoft wants examples of why we feel FoxPro has been badly treated and how they can help and here is a classic one. (I'm sure many VFP shops have similar stories)

Now, the report does not note who the FBI personnel were who said that "VFP is difficult" - but look at the words being used : "old", "difficult","slow to customize","aging code format". Let's deal with these separately:

Old. OK. Java is "newer" compared to VFP but C++ isn't. Uh - and unless I'm mistaken, there are still some mainframes in use in the US government.

Difficult. What programming language isn't slightly "difficult"? (is VFP any more difficult than, say , VB?).

Slow to Customize? That's more an attribute of the application itself. I'm sure that Windows is slow to customize as evidenced by the fact that you have to regression test it for millions of users, compared to a Linux or other O/S. One FoxPro application may be incredibly easy to customize whereas another is incredibly difficult - that doesn't mean FoxPro is slow to customize.

Aging code format - I wonder how many lines of code in VFP are STILL the same as they were back in 1990. Calvin? Any ideas?

Now I'm not intentionally trying to spin this (see the various discussions on WinFS, for examples of Spin) but I am holding this up as an example of the challenges that FoxPro developers face regularly. None of the comments are true of the language or tool itself - yet inexperienced IT program managers or knowledge workers might read this and think otherwise. Is this Microsoft's or the Fox Team's fault?

No - but clearly this is where better responses are needed. Maybe, someone should flash up the TIOBE index. Sending over case studies would be one option but once again, IT's PRODUCT SPECIFIC - so it doesn't answer the question.

Maybe we should show the life cycle for extended product support.
VFP 9 - 13/01/2015
Access 2000 - 14/07/2009
Access 2003 - 14/01/2014
Visual Interdev (how many web apps were deployed) -30/09/2004
Visual Studio 2003 - 08/10/2013

How do you combat this type of ignorance? Can you?

I don't have the answers here - do you? How would you respond?


Unknown said…
Andrew - this is a serious problem for our community. I've been toying with the idea of creating a 'foxpro successes' web site for posting success stories that don't otherwise get acknowledged. I'm willing to develop the site but I don't have the desire to hunt for the stories or write the articles on a continuing basis. If you know of a few people who would be interested in doing that work, I'm ready to start the site now!
Anonymous said…
This is a great idea!
I would like to share my success (VFP) stories in a site like this.

See also here

and here
Bill said…
This was a great post, and, in my opinion, exactly the kind of 'misinformation' we, as a community, are up against.

The current gig I'm on, when I arrived, the entire shop was under the impression that FoxPro was no longer being sold by Microsoft!!

They have several VFP 6.0 apps that they finally gave the go ahead to upgrade to vfp 9.0, once I showed them that there was, in fact, a new release by MS...

I'm currently revamping one of my sites and intend to add in some RSS feed lnks for exactly this kind of story.

Found your blog, because someone searched mine and I was checking the results of the search.

Popular posts from this blog

Blogs and RSS come to

MS has just introduced their portal and it's pretty comprehensive. Nothing quite like learning that some people use AIM instead of MSN messenger, or that there really may be a need for supporting 4 monitors ( Cyrus Complains ) However, it's really a great sign that MS is serious about supporting the blogging community which seems to have um, exploded in size in the past year. Blogs and RSS come to

FoxInCloud Stats

FoxInCloud sent this link a while back about their statistics regarding visits to their site: What's interesting here is the breakdown of people. Yes, I think it's understandable that the Fox community is getting older. Another factor is the growth of the mobile and web environments taking over development. These environments really do push people towards the newer non-SQL or free SQL/hosted environments but more towards hosted storage options like Amazon and Google. A tool like FoxInCloud that helps MOVE existing applications to the cloud inherently competes with those environments. But FoxInCloud also allows developers to extend their application further by giving them a starting point using Javascript and the basic CSS (such as Bootstrap). If you're not rebuilding your application from scratch, it's certainly a great step forward. FoxPro VFP

Facebook Revolt - imeem alternatives?

When Scoble noted how Facebook under major revolt , I immediately thought of a site I found yesterday. The value offered by Facebook's feeds however do seem very cool - if only they had been smart and made them opt-in, instead of opt-out. I have been impressed though with Facebook's opening of their API's - they certainly get it that they need to open it up to developers. I haven't really explored this other site, beyond my first look. In some ways, I think the whole social networking site thing is just silly , but this site (imeem) definitely showed some value. I could find music (as posted by the artist), it worked in Firefox and it allowed people to rank, add to delicious and more. And when I'm looking at someone, I can see what they're up to (or rather what they allow us to see). Anyways, you may want to check it out.